Saturday, May 30, 2009
Going Back to School
The piece is about how the GOP has lowered itself this week with petty attacks on Judge Sotomayor, the nominee for the SCOTUS. As BW Readers know, I have some reservations about a few of her rulings (and the spin out of the WH). However, I do think Newt, Rush, Rove, Freddie the Beetle, and Tancredo (the only elected one of the bunch) have hurt their own party by going on the attack. (Think Progress has a very terse condensed post about the attacks). Ms. Noonan said that one person told her they had to have a fight to energize the base and she questioned the wisdom of that tactic:
Excite the base? How about excite a moderate, or interest an independent? How about gain the attention of people who aren't already on your side?
And then she steps up to point out the fallacy:
The base is plenty excited already, as you know if you've ever read a comment thread on a conservative blog. Comment-thread conservatives, like their mirror-image warriors on the left ("Worst person in the woooorrrlllddd!") are perpetually agitated, permanently enraged. They don't need to be revved, they're already revved.
Ms. Noonan then admonishes Newt:
Newt Gingrich twitters that Judge Sotomayor is a racist. Does anyone believe that? He should rest his dancing thumbs, stop trying to position himself as the choice and voice of the base in 2012, and think.
I wouldn't call that a smackdown at all. But she is politely labeling Newt's behavior as immature.
Noonan is not one to just point out the fallacies though. She offers some grown-up advice:
The choice for Republicans isn't between "attack" and "roll over." It's broader than that, and more interesting. There's a new and fresh opportunity here for Republicans in the Senate to be serious, and, in their seriousness, to be seen and understood in a new light.And a more positive approach is opined here:
Republicans can be liberated by the fact that they're outnumbered and likely about to lose. They can step back, breathe in, and use the Sotomayor confirmation hearings to perform a public service: Find out what the future justice thinks and why she thinks it, explain what they think and why they think it, look at the two different philosophies, if that's what they are. Don't make it sparring, make it thinking.Newt Gingrich always prides himself for being a thinker, for one who seeks solutions. The conservative base of the GOP, particularly in Freeperville, always found him to be thoughtful.
But now, his hero's speech writer is taking him and the GOP back to school. Kathleen Parker may be one of the instructors too.
Friday, May 29, 2009
Portia De Rossi's PSA
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
Axelrod Obama Spins about the SCOTUS Pick
But as it strives to uphold President Obama’s pledge to seek “middle ground” in the abortion debate, the administration has cited the case in e-mail messages and conference calls with socially moderate outside advocates, said the Rev. Samuel Rodriguez, president of the evangelical National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference, who learned about the case from the White House.
“She went against the abortion lobby,” Mr. Rodriguez said. “The spin was that Obama did not reach into the far left and that is great for me and it is great for my constituents.”As a prominent figure in a fast-growing group with one foot on each side of the aisle — evangelical Hispanics, Mr. Rodriguez is avidly courted by Democrats and Republicans alike, and the Sotomayor nomination posed an emotional dilemma, he said.
Enter Glenn Greenwald, a constitutional lawyer whose opinion I trust, has a different take on Judge Sotomayor, partly as a lawyer who argued a couple of cases in her circuit, and partly, arguing the case of a Latina judge on the court to balance it:
Obama has also ignored the deeply dishonest right-wing attacks on Sotomayor, beginning with the inane objection to her perfectly benign and accurate comments on videotape that appellate judges, as distinct from district court judges, "make policy." Lawyer Anonymous Liberal thoroughly eviscerated that line of attack as the shallow and deceitful argument it is. A similar avenue of certain attack -- that Sotomayor said in a 2001 speech that a female Latina judge has experiences that can inform her view of cases -- is equally frivolous. There are a whole range of discretionary judgments which judges are required to make; does anyone actually doubt that familiarity with a wide range of cultural experiences is an asset?
I think Glenn also decided to deflect the wingnuts immediately.
Too bad Obama's PR team believed the POTUS had to spin it further. He didn't need to; however, it seems to me that he is trying to reinact his classes at U of Chicago Law School as a pragmatist.
One concern is that despite similar personal economic and educational backgrounds of Obama (albeit he never lived in Sec 8 housing that I am aware of as Judge Sotomayor did-- and it's good to have those who with some help moved up--) and Sotomayor, she will not lean enough on corporations about labor issues or protection clauses. I'm concerned about class actions suits being dismissed against Wall Street. (h/t glacierpeaks at Open Left). Fits in with Timmeh G and the banksters, as Atrios calls them.
Wedge issue cases, which are also filed protection clauses are anyone's guess. She may be Souter in reverse (maybe HW Bush should have picked her, if he wanted more conservative views).
I'm also concerned that VP Joe Biden may have been overruled on this one. Hillary Clinton's influence may be been at play, but I cannot and won't try to pursue that fleeting thought.
No drama-- President Obama. I have to remind him that yes, the middle helped him get elected, but that the GOP already waged war on him on his first month. Take your chances on this one, Mr. President. But if this is a close vote, as it was on the budget, then the test balloons are over. I should hope that you will move more progressively to the left on the bus. Conservatives don't rule the chickenhouses anymore.
Axelrod tried to spin the same thing on John Edwards 5 years ago. And Elizabeth said that Axelrod often didn't reflect John's real views.
Update: Sotomayor has an anti-1st Amendment ruling as of last year. (h/t to a friend on FB)
Monday, May 25, 2009
Obama Delivers an Empathetic Message of Remembrance
The transcript I got from All that Matters blog. Somehow, they got it from the WH Press Office, albeit only an excerpt was available at the WH blog. Nonetheless, here it is in its entirety, with some commentary from yours truly. I hope BW readers will find it worthy of a read.
IntroductionNote: the last comment is borrowed from the inscription of the tombs of the unknown, "Here rests in honored glory an American soldier known but to God.", established at Arlington National Cemetery to inter the remains of the first Unknown Soldier, a World War I fighter, on November 11, 1921. More were added over time.
THE PRESIDENT: Thank you, Admiral Mullen, for that generous introduction and for your sterling service to our country. To members of our armed forces, to our veterans, to honored guests, and families of the fallen — I am deeply honored to be with you on Memorial Day.
Thank you to the superintendent, John Metzler, Jr., who cares for these grounds just as his father did before him; to the Third Infantry Regiment who, regardless of weather or hour, guard the sanctity of this hallowed ground with the reverence it deserves — we are grateful to you; to service members from every branch of the military who, each Memorial Day, place an American flag before every single stone in this cemetery — we thank you as well. (Applause.) We are indebted — we are indebted to all who tend to this sacred place.
Here lie Presidents and privates; Supreme Court justices and slaves; generals familiar to history, and unknown soldiers known only to God.
A few moments ago, I laid a wreath at their tomb to pay tribute to all who have given their lives for this country. As a nation, we have gathered here to repeat this ritual in moments of peace, when we pay our respects to the fallen and give thanks for their sacrifice. And we’ve gathered here in moments of war, when the somber notes of Taps echo through the trees, and fresh grief lingers in the air.Contrast that to the tone of what our last POTUS said, about at the some moment of his speech:
Today is one of those moments, where we pay tribute to those who forged our history, but hold closely the memory of those so recently lost. And even as we gather here this morning, all across America, people are pausing to remember, to mourn, and to pray.
Old soldiers are pulling themselves a little straighter to salute brothers lost a long time ago. Children are running their fingers over colorful ribbons that they know signify something of great consequence, even if they don’t know exactly why. Mothers are re-reading final letters home and clutching photos of smiling sons or daughters, as youthful and vibrant as they always will be.
They, and we, are the legacies of an unbroken chain of proud men and women who served their country with honor; who waged war so that we might know peace; who braved hardship so that we might know opportunity; who paid the ultimate price so we might know freedom.
A few moments ago, I placed a wreath upon the tomb of three brave Americans who gave their lives in service to our nation. The names ofthese honored are known only to the Creator who delivered them home from the anguish of war -- but their valor is known to us all. It's the same valor that endured the stinging cold of Valley Forge. It is the same valor that planted the proud colors of a great nation on a mountaintop on Iwo Jima. It is the same valor that charged fearlessly through the assault of enemy fire from the mountains of Afghanistan to the deserts of Iraq. It is the valor that has defined the armed forces of the United States of America throughout our history.
Today, we gather to honor those who gave everything to preserve our way of life. The men and women we honor here served for liberty. They sacrificed for liberty. And in countless acts of courage, they died for liberty. From faraway lands, they were returned to cemeteries like this one, where broken hearts received their broken bodies -- they found peace beneath the white headstones in the land they fought to defend.
It is a solemn reminder of the cost of freedom that the number of headstones in a place such as this grows with every new Memorial Day. In a world where freedom is constantly under attack and in a world where our security is challenged, the joys of liberty are often purchased by the sacrifices of those who serve a cause greater than themselves. Today we mourn and remember all who have given their lives in the line of duty. Today we lift up our hearts especially those who've fallen in the past year.
The tone is not reflective, it is more "rah, rah" and the manly hubis of war. Why we need to be afraid, and how freedom is always under attack. How the joys of liberty are bought with war. Yuck.
President Obama then starts examining the historical meaning of this day:
Those who rest in these fields fought in every American war. They overthrew an empire and gave birth to revolution. They strained to hold a young union together. They rolled back the creeping tide of tyranny, and stood post through a long twilight struggle. And they took on the terror and extremism that threatens our world’s stability.And hence the significance of the cemetery, and how it is laid out according to the generations of the fallen:
Their stories are the American story. More than seven generations of them are chronicled here at Arlington. They’re etched into stone, recounted by family and friends, and silently observed by the mighty oaks that have stood over burial after burial.
To walk these grounds then is to walk through that history. Not far from here, appropriately just across a bridge connecting Lincoln to Lee, Union and Confederate soldiers share the same land in perpetuity.
Just down the sweeping hill behind me rest those we lost in World War II, fresh-faced GIs who rose to the moment by unleashing a fury that saved the world. Next week, I’ll visit Normandy, the place where our fate hung on an operation unlike any ever attempted, where it will be my tremendous honor to address some of the brave men who stormed those beaches 65 years ago.Obama brings up memories of the Vietnam Wall, and ties it with today's new generation of those who served in Iraq and Afghanistan, in that we have rituals that include symbols, and what they mean to keep their memories alive. (this is also when I felt teardrops trickle down my face)
And tucked in a quiet corner to our north are thousands of those we lost in Vietnam. We know for many the casualties of that war endure — right now, there are veterans suffering and families tracing their fingers over black granite not two miles from here. They are why we pledge anew to remember their service and revere their sacrifice, and honor them as they deserve.
This cemetery is in and of itself a testament to the price our nation has paid for freedom. A quarter of a million marble headstones dot these rolling hills in perfect military order, worthy of the dignity of those who rest here. It can seem overwhelming. But for the families of the fallen, just one stone stands out — one stone that requires no map to find.
Today, some of those stones are found at the bottom of this hill in Section 60, where the fallen from Iraq and Afghanistan rest. The wounds of war are fresh in Section 60. A steady stream of visitors leaves reminders of life: photos, teddy bears, favorite magazines. Friends place small stones as a sign they stopped by. Combat units leave bottles of beer or stamp cigarettes into the ground as a salute to those they rode in battle with. Perfect strangers visit in their free time, compelled to tend to these heroes, to leave flowers, to read poetry — to make sure they don’t get lonely.
Then the President offers these questions, as though he is talking to the families and friends philosophically:
If the fallen could speak to us, what would they say? Would they console us? Perhaps they might say that while they could not know they’d be called upon to storm a beach through a hail of gunfire, they were willing to give up everything for the defense of our freedom; that while they could not know they’d be called upon to jump into the mountains of Afghanistan and seek an elusive enemy, they were willing to sacrifice all for their country; that while they couldn’t possibly know they would be called to leave this world for another, they were willing to take that chance to save the lives of their brothers and sisters in arms.Obama's questions are heartfelt, and even though he doesn't have a specific answer, he believes we could only surmise:
What is thing, this sense of duty? What tugs at a person until he or she says “Send me”? Why, in an age when so many have acted only in pursuit of the narrowest self-interest, have the soldiers, sailors, airmen and Marines of this generation volunteered all that they have on behalf of others? Why have they been willing to bear the heaviest burden?
Whatever it is, they felt some tug; they answered a call; they said “I’ll go.” That is why they are the best of America, and that is what separates them from those of us who have not served in uniform — their extraordinary willingness to risk their lives for people they never met.
My grandfather served in Patton’s Army in World War II. But I cannot know what it is like to walk into battle. I’m the father of two young girls — but I can’t imagine what it’s like to lose a child. These are things I cannot know. But I do know this: I am humbled to be the Commander-in-Chief of the finest fighting force in the history of the world.
And Obama reiterated his message from Thursday to Dick Cheney and his ilk who keep spouting off nonsense that our President is losing the ball on security, but added, there has to be strong intelligence to support reason to put our Americans in harm's way:
I know that there is nothing I will not do to keep our country safe, even as I face no harder decision than sending our men and women to war — and no moment more difficult than writing a letter to the families of the fallen. And that’s why as long as I am President, I will only send our troops into harm’s way when it is absolutely necessary, and I will always provide them with the equipment and support they need to get the job done. (Applause.)Amen, Mr. President. We know all too well the ill-planned war to invade Iraq, and Rumsfeld didn't prepare for a long ground invasion either.
I know that military families sacrifice more than we can understand, and feel an absence greater than we can comprehend. And that’s why Michelle and I are committed to easing their burden.Indeed, Obama included more money in his budget for the Department of Veterans Affairs for more quality care and services to the vets. Something that was somehow unimportant under the last Administration.
And I know what a grateful nation owes to those who serve under its proud flag. And that’s why I promise all our servicemen and women that when the guns fall silent, and you do return home, it will be to an America that is forever here for you, just as you’ve been there for us. (Applause.)
Obama brings us back to the "Memorial " part of the service:
With each death, we are heartbroken. With each death, we grow more determined. This bustling graveyard can be a restless place for the living, where solace sometimes comes only from meeting others who know similar grief. But it reminds us all the meaning of valor; it reminds us all of our own obligations to one another; it recounts that most precious aspect of our history, and tells us that we will only rise or fall together.And to conclude:
So on this day of silent remembrance and solemn prayer I ask all Americans, wherever you are, whoever you’re with, whatever you’re doing, to pause in national unity at 3:00 this afternoon. I ask you to ring a bell, or offer a prayer, say a silent “thank you.” And commit to give something back to this nation — something lasting — in their memory; to affirm in our own lives and advance around the world those enduring ideals of justice, equality, and opportunity for which they and so many generations of Americans have given that last full measure of devotion.
God bless you, God bless the fallen, and God bless the United States of America.
Thank you, Mr. President, in truly delivering a spirit of memory, healing, and empathy.
Note: this diary post will continue to be tweaked, so there will be some changes here and there.